How do referees integrate evaluation criteria into their overall judgment? Evidence from grant peer review
SE Hug - Scientometrics, 2024 - Springer
Little is known whether peer reviewers use the same evaluation criteria and how they
integrate the criteria into their overall judgment. This study therefore proposed two …
integrate the criteria into their overall judgment. This study therefore proposed two …
Targeted, actionable and fair: Reviewer reports as feedback and its effect on ECR career choices
Previous studies of the use of peer review for the allocation of competitive funding agencies
have concentrated on questions of efficiency and how to make the 'best'decision, by …
have concentrated on questions of efficiency and how to make the 'best'decision, by …
Peer review's irremediable flaws: Scientists' perspectives on grant evaluation in Germany
E Barlösius, L Paruschke, A Philipps - Research Evaluation, 2023 - academic.oup.com
Peer review has developed over time to become the established procedure for assessing
and assuring the scientific quality of research. Nevertheless, the procedure has also been …
and assuring the scientific quality of research. Nevertheless, the procedure has also been …
Promoting equality, diversity and inclusion in research and funding: reflections from a digital manufacturing research network
Background Equal, diverse, and inclusive teams lead to higher productivity, creativity, and
greater problem-solving ability resulting in more impactful research. However, there is a gap …
greater problem-solving ability resulting in more impactful research. However, there is a gap …
Perceptions of grant peer reviewers: a mixed methods study
KB Schmaling, GR Evenson, BK Marble… - Research …, 2024 - academic.oup.com
Peer review is integral to the evaluation of grant proposals. Reviewer perceptions and
characteristics have received limited study, especially their associations with reviewers' …
characteristics have received limited study, especially their associations with reviewers' …
Research in Latin America: bases for the foundation of a training program in higher education
M Marino-Jiménez, IL Ramírez-Durand… - Cogent …, 2024 - Taylor & Francis
Research is a common feature in developed countries. Those who dedicate themselves to
this activity produce important tools for individual, community, and national development …
this activity produce important tools for individual, community, and national development …
DecentPeeR: A Self-Incentivised & Inclusive Decentralized Peer Review System
J Gruendler, D Melnyk… - … on Blockchain and …, 2024 - ieeexplore.ieee.org
Peer review, as a widely used practice to ensure the quality and integrity of publications,
lacks a well-defined and common mechanism to self-incentivize virtuous behavior across all …
lacks a well-defined and common mechanism to self-incentivize virtuous behavior across all …
Peer reviewers' conflicts of interest in biomedical research: sco** review
Background Peer review may improve the quality of research manuscripts and aid in
editorial decisions, but reviewers can have conflicts of interest that impact on their …
editorial decisions, but reviewers can have conflicts of interest that impact on their …
Peer reviewer topic choice and its impact on interrater reliability: A mixed-method study
One of the main critiques of academic peer review is that interrater reliability (IRR) among
reviewers is low. We examine an underinvestigated factor possibly contributing to low IRR …
reviewers is low. We examine an underinvestigated factor possibly contributing to low IRR …
[HTML][HTML] Role, function, and expectations of research funding committees: Perspectives from committee members
A Blatch-Jones, C Boxall, K Meadmore - F1000Research, 2025 - f1000research.com
Research funding committees play an integral role in the research funding process,
consisting of a range of skills, knowledge, and expertise (eg, professional, and public …
consisting of a range of skills, knowledge, and expertise (eg, professional, and public …