A synthesis of the formats for correcting erroneous and fraudulent academic literature, and associated challenges

JA Teixeira da Silva - Journal for general philosophy of science, 2022 - Springer
Academic publishing is undergoing a highly transformative process, and many established
rules and value systems that are in place, such as traditional peer review (TPR) and …

“Flawed, but like democracy we don't have a better system”: The Experts' Insights on the Peer Review Process of Evaluating Security Papers

A Soneji, FB Kokulu, C Rubio-Medrano… - … IEEE Symposium on …, 2022 - ieeexplore.ieee.org
The academic computer security community has traditionally adopted peer review as an
integral part of scientific publishing and dissemination, in a process that grows organically …

Progressive and degenerative journals: On the growth and appraisal of knowledge in scholarly publishing

DJ Dunleavy - European Journal for Philosophy of Science, 2022 - Springer
Despite continued attention, finding adequate criteria for distinguishing “good” from “bad”
scholarly journals remains an elusive goal. In this essay, I propose a solution informed by …

Research Note—Making Peer Review Evidence-Based: It's Time to Open the “Black Box”

DJ Dunleavy - Journal of Social Work Education, 2024 - Taylor & Francis
Peer review serves an essential role in the cultivation, validation, and dissemination of
social work scholarship. Nevertheless, the current peer review system has been described …

Is Social Work Research in Crisis?

DJ Dunleavy, JR Lacasse - Research on Social Work …, 2023 - journals.sagepub.com
In recent years, the veracity of scientific findings has come under intense scrutiny in what
has been called the “replication crisis.” This crisis is marked by the propagation of scientific …

Can open peer review improve uptake of preprints into policies? Evidence from a causal inference

C Xu, Q Zong - Science and Public Policy, 2024 - academic.oup.com
The advantage of no publication time lag had led to the use of preprints as research
evidence for public policy development that required a rapid response. However, the …

Making peer review evidence-based: It's time to open the" black box"

DJ Dunleavy - 2022 - osf.io
Peer review serves an essential role in the cultivation, validation, and dissemination of
social work knowledge and scholarship. Nevertheless, the current peer review system has …

The use and misuse of classical statistics: A primer for social workers

DJ Dunleavy, JR Lacasse - Research on Social Work …, 2021 - journals.sagepub.com
In this article, we offer a primer on “classical” frequentist statistics. In doing so, we aim to (1)
provide social workers with a nuanced overview of common statistical concepts and tools,(2) …

Historical assessment of three extinct portable peer review and cascade peer review models

JA Teixeira da Silva - Library and Information Science Research E …, 2023 - dr.ntu.edu.sg
Portable peer review (PPR) refers to peer review that is not conducted by a journal but
instead by externally recruited peers whose reports are then made available to that journal's …

Assessing for Bias and Evidential Value: Introducing the P-Curve to Social Work Research

DJ Dunleavy - Social Work Research, 2022 - academic.oup.com
Method The sample described here is based in part on a larger, unpublished meta-research
study (Dunleavy, 2020a) that surveyed and analyzed statistical reporting practices and …